SEA Youth Say So
News, Culture & Travel from Southeast Asia



News

December 12, 2011

Made By Migrants – Stories of construction workers in Singapore

Made By Migrants
I

t’s impossible not to cross paths with a migrant worker these days. We see them everywhere: fixing our roads, cutting the grass, clambering over construction sites. Everyone seems to have something to say about these workers, be it good or bad. They’ve been discussed in the context of economics, immigration and human rights. But who are these workers? What are their names? What did they used to do? Why have them come here, and who have they left behind?

The team: Ian from Manchester, Victoria from Sydney and Mark from Singapore.

Made By Migrants is a project that seeks to, if not answer, at least shed a little light on these questions. Done by three interns from advertising agency Bartle Bogle Hegarty (BBH) Singapore, it “aims to look past the skin-deep perceptions of migrant workers by revealing their motivations, stories and dreams.”

And they’re not just settling for photographs and snatched conversations with migrant workers. Team member Ian has been living and working alongside migrant workers at a construction site. He has already been attached with them for a week, with another more to go.

“Ian has never travelled anywhere before this. He came with no preconceptions,” Victoria tells me over lunch.

Before embarking on this project the team had also been briefed not to make it too political or critical. But that was never their plan, anyway. With two out of three members being non-Singaporeans, none of them wanted the project to be overly-critical of Singapore. “That would just have been disrespectful,” says Victoria.

The point of Made By Migrants is not to criticise Singapore’s immigration or labour policies, nor to accuse anyone – employers or workers – of bad behaviour. It is merely an attempt to hear the stories behind the workers here in Singapore building our roads and MRT stations and homes.

Sunsheng, one of the workers

While spending time with the workers in their container dormitory and working with them on site, Ian updates the Made By Migrants blog with photographs, entries, audio and video. Whenever possible he does interviews with the workers, asking them about how and why they came to Singapore, what they were doing before, and what they hope for in the future. Through these stories we’re able to identify and relate to these workers and their motivations, and to realise that they are much more than rubber boots and fluorescent safety vests; they are people just like us, people with families and responsibilities and hopes.

Not all of the feedback has been positive. Some of the comments are just petty, Victoria tells me, while others dismiss the project as nothing more than “middle class guilt”, a gimmick that doesn’t particularly do anything to help the workers.

“It’s not about giving them anything,” she explains. “It’s about humanising them and learning about their motivations. We’re the ones in the position to do something. It’s not middle class guilt, it’s middle class responsibility.”

She doesn’t hide the fact that there are certain limitations, the most crucial one being a lack of time. The internship comes to an end next week, and Ian and Victoria are both going home to Manchester and Sydney in the weekend. Due to the time it took to get Ian a placement (Victoria estimates that they had to call about 50 people each) there’s not much time for Ian to get to know the workers even better, or explore issues more in depth. But they hope that the blog will continue to be shared, and that people will be encouraged to think of the migrant workers in a different way.

Ultimately, it’s not a perfect project. There are many “if only”s and “what if”s. It might not be enough to change people’s mindsets, especially when there are so many Singaporeans still so frustrated and angry with the influx of foreign workers.

But it’s a start, a small step towards a greater understanding of the people who build the physical structures in which we live out our lives. The rest will be up to us.

Facebook: Made By Migrants
Twitter: @MadeByMigrants
Website: www.madebymigrants.com



About the Author

Kirsten Han
Kirsten Han (Singapore) is one of the two editors of SEAYSS. She is a blogger and multi-tasker interested in human rights issues. She also likes to travel, take photographs and – above all else – tell stories. She blogs at #spuddings.




 
Related Posts
 

 
asean-youth

Youth Exchange Program: Asean Youth and the Revolving Regional Architecture

The ASEAN Studies Center of Chulalongkorn University (ASC) is now calling for students who are studying in universities in ASEAN Member Countries to join the ASEAN Youth Exchange Program entitled “ASEAN Youth &The Evolvin...
by seayouthsayso
0

 
 
free-the-13

FREE THE THIRTEEN: Call to Action

Freedom of expression is not a crime!  Yet, thirteen peace activists in Myanmar have been charged by police and could face 10 years jail time for leading peaceful marches on 21st September 2012, which also marked UN’s Intern...
by seayouthsayso
0

 
 
Opportunities, Stuff to Apply For

The Gerald Segal Research Internship 2012-13

The following was first posted on IISS’ website: The International Institute for Strategic Studies-Asia (IISS-Asia) invites applications for the Gerald Segal Research Internship 2012-13, which will be tenable for a period...
by seayouthsayso
0

 




Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

Trackbacks

  1. [...] Kirsten Han interviewed the group and reviewed their project It’s impossible not to cross paths with a migrant worker these days. We see them everywhere: fixing our roads, cutting the grass, clambering over construction sites. Everyone seems to have something to say about these workers, be it good or bad. They’ve been discussed in the context of economics, immigration and human rights. But who are these workers? What are their names? What did they used to do? Why have them come here, and who have they left behind? [...]

  2. [...] Kirsten Han intervjuade gruppen och tog en titt på deras projekt It’s impossible not to cross paths with a migrant worker these days. We see them everywhere: fixing our roads, cutting the grass, clambering over construction sites. Everyone seems to have something to say about these workers, be it good or bad. They’ve been discussed in the context of economics, immigration and human rights. But who are these workers? What are their names? What did they used to do? Why have them come here, and who have they left behind? [...]

  3. [...] Kirsten Han przeprowadziła wywiad z grupą i zrecenzowała ich projekt. W dzisiejszych czasach nie da się nie spotkać na swojej drodze pracowników z innych krajów. Widzimy ich wszędzie: naprawiających nasze drogi, koszących trawniki, chodzących  po budowach.  Każdy ma coś dobrego czy złego do powiedzenia na ich temat. Dyskutowano o nich w kontekście ekonomii, imigracji i praw człowieka.  Ale kim właściwie są ci robotnicy? Jak mają na imię? Czym się zajmowali wcześniej? Czemu tu przyjechali, i kogo zostawili w domu? Projekt Made By Migrants nie próbuje odpowiedzieć na wszystkie te kwestie, ale na pewno rzuci na nie trochę światła. [...]

  4. [...] Kristen Hanは、このグループにインタビューをし、彼らのプロジェクトを振り返った。 最近では、出稼ぎ労働者に出会わないことが難しいほどだ。あらゆるところで彼らを見かける。道路整備をするものや、草刈りをするもの、また建築現場によじ登ったりするものもいる。誰もがこうした労働者について、良くも悪くも、何らかの意見を持っているようだ。これまで、経済、移民及び人権の点から議論が交わされてきた。しかし、こうした労働者とはいったい誰なのか?名前は?以前は何をしていたのか?どんな経緯でここに来たのか?故郷に残してきた者たちは? [...]

  5. [...] 克斯坦汉 (Kirsten Han)访问了这群实习生并回顾这次的专题计划。 我们现在每天几乎都能接触到外来劳工,无论是道路修缮处、须修剪杂草的地方,还是建筑工地的鹰架上,都能看到他们的身影。 大家对 这些外来劳工或多或少都会有些想法(不管是好是坏);在经济、移民或人权议题的背景脉络中,外来移民也成了考量因素。但是,这些工人到底是谁?他们叫什么 名字?他们以前在自己家乡是做什么的?为什么他们要到新加坡工作?他们的家乡还有谁在等着他们呢? [...]